Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

Experts have warned about an illegal scheme withholding salaries upon dismissal

Lukinova: an employer cannot withhold a salary as a pledge for an employee's departure
0
Photo: IZVESTIA/Anna Selina
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

Companies have started using the practice of withholding part of their salaries as a "deposit" in case of sudden employee layoffs. However, such a scheme has no legal basis and violates the norms of labor legislation. As a result, employers may face fines and demands to return the withheld funds. All the details are in the Izvestia article.

Illegality of financial deductions

Russian legislation does not contain the concept of a "deposit for sudden dismissal." The employer does not have the right to withhold part of the employee's salary as collateral or compensation for possible inconveniences associated with the employee's departure. Sofya Lukinova, Head of the Legal Department at VMT Consult, explained that the Labor Code of the Russian Federation provides for withholding funds only in limited cases. For example, it may be the repayment of an unprocessed advance, erroneously paid amounts, or repayment of other debts directly provided for by law.

At the same time, the company's possible costs of finding a new employee or difficulties in replacing an employee are not grounds for withholding wages. According to the lawyer, even if the condition for non-repayment of such a "deposit" is prescribed in the employment contract, it has no legal force, as it contradicts the law.

"The deposit scheme directly violates labor laws. The employer may face fines under Article 5.27 of the Administrative Code of the Russian Federation, as well as an order to return to the employee all illegally withheld amounts," said Sofya Lukinova.

The expert noted that it is possible to collect expenses for education or training from an employee only in certain cases. For example, if an apprenticeship agreement was signed with an employee, in which the terms of study and the obligations of the parties were specified in advance. In all other situations, attempts to demand money for an urgent search for a new employee or replacement of an employee will be illegal.

Why do companies use such schemes?

According to Anna Alikova, an independent HR expert, such practices are more common in areas with high staff turnover, such as retail, catering, and warehouses. Employers are trying to reduce the number of sudden layoffs and retain employees in this way, but financial collateral does not solve the problem of staff shortages.

"Financial pressure does not help to keep employees. On the contrary, it creates an atmosphere of distrust and fear, which is why people start looking for more comfortable conditions from other employers," Alikova said.

According to the expert, such requirements become an alarming signal for applicants. They may indicate problems with the corporate culture and the company's unwillingness to build long-term relationships with employees.

In addition to the legal consequences, this practice also carries reputational risks. It may be more difficult for an employer to attract qualified specialists if information about such conditions becomes known on the labor market.

Instead of financial constraints, companies can use other ways to retain staff: competitive pay, comfortable working conditions, adaptation programs for newcomers, and clear professional growth opportunities.

How to return illegally withheld money

According to Lukinova, if the employer does not return the withheld "deposit", the employee is advised to first send a written request for a refund. In case of refusal, the employee can contact the labor inspectorate or the prosecutor's office. These authorities have the right to conduct an inspection, issue an order to eliminate violations and hold the company accountable.

In addition, the employee can apply to the court. The time limit for applying for protection of the violated right in such a situation is one year from the moment when the money should have been paid.

Experts stressed that an employer has the right to protect its interests and calculate staff costs, but this cannot be done by illegally withholding wages.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast