Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast

The Supreme Court explained the effect of CTP in the absence of the fault of the participants in the accident

0
Photo: TASS/Alexander Ryumin
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The Supreme Court of the Russian Federation considered the case of a dispute over insurance payments after an accident, pointing out the need for a culprit to apply the CTP regulations. This was announced on August 11 by the press service of the supreme court.

The reason for the proceedings was the claim of the car owner to the insurance company for the recovery of unpaid insurance compensation, as well as to the administration of Volgograd for damages. The accident occurred at a site where the "Give way" sign was covered by a tree crown, which, according to the plaintiff, was the cause of the accident. The insurer paid only half of the amount, citing the lack of an established degree of guilt of the participants in the incident.

The courts of the first, appellate and cassation instances supported the plaintiff's claims.: Unpaid compensation was collected from the insurer, and losses and court costs were collected from the city administration. The insurance company challenged these decisions in the Supreme Court, pointing out the incorrect application of the CTP legislation. According to the insurer, the insured event did not occur, because the fault of the participants in the accident was not established, and the actions of the city administration are not subject to the regulation of CTP.

The Board of Civil Affairs of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation agreed with this position. The definition states that when sources of increased danger interact, civil liability arises only if one of the participants is at fault. In this case, the fault of the drivers has not been established, so there are no grounds for insurance payments.

At the same time, the court pointed out that the cause of the accident was improper maintenance of the road infrastructure, and the duty to compensate for damage should be assigned to the city administration in full. The case has been sent for a new review.

As reported on August 3, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation recognized the permissible reuse of the mouthpiece of the breathalyzer when checking one driver. The relevant decision was made following a complaint from a resident of the Nizhny Novgorod region, who was fined 30,000 rubles and suspended for a year and a half for driving under the influence.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast