Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

In response to the deputy's request, the Supreme Court clarified that the use of magnetic frames to attach car license plates is not an offense. However, last fall, in a similar situation, Russia's highest court found a motorist guilty of traffic violations. Lawyers and experts are ambivalent about the use of non-standard mounting elements for license plates. The details are in the Izvestia article.

They dropped the number

Magnetic frames for attaching registration plates to a car are not a device that will hide or make it difficult to identify the license plate. This follows from the response of the Supreme Court (SC RF), signed by the head of the Department for systematization of legislation and analysis of judicial practice of the SC RF to the relevant deputy request. A copy of the letter is available to Izvestia.

Фемида
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

The response of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation states that when qualifying an act under Part 2 of Article 12.2 of the Administrative Code of the Russian Federation ("Management of vehicles with state registration marks equipped with devices that prevent the identification of state registration marks, or allow them to be modified or hidden"), it is necessary to determine whether the corresponding device has properties that prevent identification of the number or provide the possibility of hiding or modifying it.

"At the same time, any specific design or method of fastening the state registration mark does not per se belong to such devices," the Supreme Court's letter emphasizes.

Meanwhile, last fall, the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation refused to satisfy the complaint of a citizen who was deprived of his rights for a year for using a "shifter" frame that had not been activated. As follows from the court's ruling, the very fact of installing special devices on the vehicle to hide the license plate constitutes an offense.

A letter is not a document

The Supreme Court's response to the deputy's request cannot be regarded as permission to use such a framework for a license plate, Sergei Radko, a lawyer for the Freedom of Choice movement, is convinced. This letter is not an official document of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, and therefore does not entail any legal consequences, he noted.

Суд
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

— In fact, the Supreme Court's response is nothing more than an ordinary correspondence between the two departments. It cannot be interpreted as "the court allowed". Only official court decisions have legal force, such as resolutions and rulings signed by a judge or members of the judicial board of the Supreme Court," Sergei Radko explained.

In his opinion, the issue of bringing to justice for the use of "special frames" can be analogous to firearms. By itself, having a citizen with him, for example, a pistol or a shotgun without a proper permit already constitutes a crime, the lawyer recalled. The situation is very similar with the use of any frames, brackets or other devices, objects used to install license plates on the car, Sergei Radko believes.

With bolts and screws

In Russia, GOST R 50577-2018 "State registration signs of vehicles" has been in force since 2018. Types and basic sizes. Technical requirements", which prescribes mandatory requirements for both the license plates themselves and their installation, recalls Maxim Kadakov, editor-in-chief of Za Rulem magazine. There is no mention of a "magnetic framework" in it, he emphasizes. Moreover, paragraph 5 of Appendix "G" clearly states that "bolts or screws with heads having the color of the field of the sign or light electroplating must be used to secure registration plates."

— This GOST allows the use of conventional plastic frames for rooms. But if you strictly follow the document, the signs should not only be installed in such frames and snapped with an overlay, but also bolted to the frames themselves with the same bolts or screws. Actually, there are special holes in the registration plates for this purpose. The size, which, by the way, is also regulated by GOST — no more than 7 mm, — said Maxim Kadakov.

Номер
Photo: RIA Novosti/Evgeny Biyatov

The editor—in-chief of Za Rulem noted that the use of magnetic frames for license plates has only one goal - to quickly remove and then just as quickly install the license plates on the car. For example, to drive with impunity along a stretch of road with cameras, park your car in a paid parking lot for free, and not pay for driving on a toll highway.

— Obviously, such frames are not installed on the car for beauty. Therefore, drivers who use them should be responsible for this," Maxim Kadakov is convinced.

Assumptions cannot be punished.

Sergey Smirnov, an auto lawyer, also believes that such frames are used by drivers to make the car "invisible" to cameras.

— However, these are just assumptions that arise from us, from the traffic police, and from the judge. It is impossible to find a person guilty and bring him to justice on the basis of such assumptions," he told Izvestia.

The issue of drivers using magnetic frames is quite complicated, according to auto expert Igor Morzharetto. On the one hand, they are most often used to violate traffic regulations with impunity, on the other hand, there are situations when their use is completely legitimate, he notes.

ДПС
Photo: IZVESTIA/Anna Selina

— Some motorists use a special trunk for transporting bicycles, which is attached to the tow bar of the car. But the bikes mounted on it cover both the taillights and the rear license plate. Therefore, additional lighting equipment and a separate platform for attaching a license plate are provided on such a trunk. In such a situation, in order not to unscrew and then re-screw the sign, it is quite logical to use the same magnetic frames. Obviously, in this case, it is impossible to say that their use is aimed at hiding from cameras," Igor Morzharetto gave an example.

He stressed that the law simply cannot divide all devices, objects, types of frames and brackets that can be used by motorists to attach license plates into "legal" and "illegal" ones. A more logical way is for the police and the courts to examine as objectively and thoroughly as possible all the circumstances and factors that prompted the motorist to use such a framework when deciding on his guilt or innocence, Igor Morzharetto is convinced.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast