Trump has banned "maternity tourism." What the media is writing
US President Donald Trump is again trying to limit the automatic acquisition of American citizenship by children born in the United States. To do this, on August 6, he signed two executive orders — just over a month after the Supreme Court declared his previous attempt to revoke the right to citizenship by birth unconstitutional. How the foreign press evaluates the initiative of the American president is in the Izvestia digest.
Politico: Trump is fighting "maternity tourism"
President Donald Trump has signed two executive orders aimed at restricting the right to citizenship by birth in the United States. One of the decrees concerns children born to certain categories of people: diplomats, "enemy foreigners", as well as women who enter the United States solely for the sake of having a child. The second decree instructs government agencies to develop new rules against "maternity tourism." The administration claims that the current practice is an abuse of the visa system, although independent estimates show that the number of such cases is significantly lower than the White House claims.
Politico
Trump said that these decrees would allow the administration to carry out "large-scale preventive measures" and act "much more decisively." "..." These decrees are an attempt to circumvent Trump's defeat in the Supreme Court. The administration argued that the current practice of granting citizenship by birth was contrary to the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. However, five judges — Chief Justice John Roberts, Justice Amy Coney Barrett and three liberal wing judges — concluded that the constitution guarantees the right to citizenship by birth.
These measures are seen as an attempt by Trump to circumvent the decision of the Supreme Court, which recognized that the US Constitution protects the principle of citizenship by birth. It is expected that the new decrees will also be appealed to the courts, as their compliance with the constitution and current laws is controversial.
The Guardian: The American Civil Liberties Union says that Trump's decrees are doomed to fail in court
The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) has criticized Donald Trump's new executive orders aimed at restricting birthright citizenship. The organization said that the president is trying to change the rules again, despite the fact that the US Supreme Court had previously blocked a similar initiative. According to the ACLU, presidential decrees cannot change the provisions of the constitution, which, according to the organization, guarantees citizenship to people born in the United States.
The Guardian
In a statement, the ACLU sharply criticized the president's attempt to circumvent the Supreme Court's decision and said the new decrees would not be able to withstand judicial appeal. "..." These decrees have become part of Trump's multi-year campaign, which many consider almost hopeless. He has been pushing for the abolition of the right to citizenship by birth for more than a decade, ever since he first promised to do so during an election event in 2015.
ACLU spokesman Cody Wofsi said Trump's new executive orders are likely to face the same challenges in the courts as the previous executive order. The organization is confident that any attempts to restrict the right to citizenship by birth will be considered illegal.
France 24: Trump wants to curb birthright citizenship
The Trump administration has tried to limit the right to obtain U.S. citizenship by birth, arguing that the children of illegal migrants and some foreigners should not automatically become citizens. However, lower courts blocked this initiative, citing the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, according to which almost all people born in the country are American citizens.
France 24
The 14th Amendment says: "All persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to their jurisdiction are citizens of the United States." This does not apply to those who are not under U.S. jurisdiction, such as the children of foreign diplomats.
The attempt to revoke citizenship by birth has become part of Trump's broader anti-immigration policy. His administration sought to reduce the number of illegal migrants, increase deportations and limit the protection of certain categories of foreigners, but the initiative to change the rules for obtaining citizenship faced legal obstacles and did not receive the support of the Supreme Court.
CBC: Trump attacks Birthright citizenship
The Trump administration claims that the new measures differ from the previous decree and are aimed only at restricting certain categories of people. Supporters of the restrictions refer to the problem of maternity tourism. In 2020, the Center for Immigration Research estimated that between 2016 and 2017, approximately 20-25 thousand pregnant women came to the United States annually in order to give birth to a child. For comparison, 3.6 million people were born in the United States in 2025.
CBC
There is no official data on the number of foreigners who come to the United States for the specific purpose of having a child and obtaining citizenship for him, as well as on possible costs for taxpayers. Nevertheless, the Chairman of the Supreme Court, John Roberts, wrote in his decision that the authors of the 14th Amendment extended this guarantee to every person born in the country.
The 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution was adopted after the Civil War. It states that all people born in the United States and subject to their jurisdiction are citizens of the country, with the exception of rare cases. The Chairman of the Supreme Court, John Roberts, recalled that this provision is a guarantee that has existed for more than 150 years.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»