- Статьи
- Society
- BVI with barriers: leading universities have begun to limit the admission of Olympiad students
BVI with barriers: leading universities have begun to limit the admission of Olympiad students
In recent days, before the end of admission to budget-funded Russian universities, a discussion about possible quotas of places for winners of school Olympiads has flared up again. The fact is that Olympiads often occupy all budget places in prestigious specialties in the largest educational institutions and arrange a competition among themselves. Applicants who have scored even the maximum number of points in several subjects of the Unified State Exam, in these conditions, still cannot qualify for free tuition in their favorite specialty. However, not all university leaders agree with this and continue to declare their interest in the Olympic Games. Why universities do not want to regulate this issue from above and how they intend to limit their number on their own, read the Izvestia article.
Why are you talking about quotas?
This year, a number of prestigious universities have organized an admission competition among the winners and prize-winners of the Olympiads. Under these conditions, even those with three hundred points — those who passed three Unified State Exams with maximum scores — could not apply for enrollment. There is a known case when an applicant who scored 310 points for the Unified State Exam (100 points each for three exams and 10 points for additional achievements) could not enroll in any university to which he applied. He advised schoolchildren to write Olympiads and "oust, not be ousted."
Given that this year has become a record year for the number of hundred-point students (there are more than 10 thousand of them throughout the country), the discussion about possible quotas of places in universities that can be occupied by winners and prize-winners of school Olympiads has flared up again. In particular, MGIMO Rector Anatoly Torkunov stated that it is necessary to allocate "no more than 10-15% of the total amount of budget admission to Olympiads, by analogy with special and separate quotas."
Two years ago, the Ministry of Education and Science already raised this issue: at that time, it was proposed to allocate a quota of no more than 70% of the total number of budget places for each field to Olympiads.
What is the position of universities on quotas
At a press conference on Thursday, Anatoly Torkunov confirmed his position, which was announced in the media, but this time he did not name a specific proposal for a share for Olympians with the right to enter without entrance tests (BVI). Answering a question from Izvestia, he stressed that the Olympiad system has existed for a long time, but, like any other, it will lose its effectiveness if it is not "tweaked." However, something needs to be changed "during the year, and not during the hot period of the admission campaign," the MGIMO rector emphasized.
Not all universities agree that it is necessary to introduce quota regulation for Olympiads. At the same press conference, Dmitry Livanov, rector of the Moscow Institute of Physics and Technology, stated that he opposes special regulation in this matter, since educational institutions already have enough tools to solve the issue. For example, MIPT is reducing the number of Olympiads that are considered for admission: last year there were 50 of them, this year — 35. Also in 2026, diplomas of Olympic medalists were no longer accepted — only winners (with the exception of the All-Russian Olympiad of Schoolchildren). The average score for the Unified State Exam, which must be applied to your Olympiad achievements in order to enter the university, is gradually rising: last year it was 75, this year it is 80.
"It is important for us to maintain a balance: approximately 50% of applicants are winners of the Olympics, and another 50% are based on the results of the Unified State Exam. This year, it turned out 53 to 47 in favor of the Olympic athletes," said Livanov.
Vladimir Vasiliev, Rector of ITMO University, has a similar position. In this university, more than half of the places were taken by Olympiad students, but its head assured that the educational institution has "all the mechanisms for regulating different types of admission."
Alexey Egorov, Deputy Executive Secretary of the MEPhI National Research Nuclear University Admissions Committee for Bachelor's and specialist's degrees, told Izvestia that the nuclear university also does not support the idea of quoting budget places for Olympiads.
"Such quotas will lead to a sharp increase in tension in the cohort of those children and their parents who participate in the Olympiad movement, and they get into the Olympiad movement in grades 5-6," he noted.
Other major Russian universities did not respond to requests from Izvestia. The rectors of RUDN University, RANEPA, MISIS, Plekhanov Russian University of Economics and UrFU did not state their position on this issue at the press conference.
Meanwhile, Candidate of Technical Sciences Evgeny Bely believes that the introduction of quotas is inevitable, otherwise the very idea of the Unified State Exam as a tool providing equal opportunities for applicants will be discredited.
— I believe that the 10-15% target proposed by the MGIMO rector is clearly underestimated. My option is 50-50, that is, to give half of the remaining places after the quotas to the Olympic athletes, and half to the applicants for the Unified State Exam," the source told Izvestia.
He admitted that in this case some Olympiads would "die," but this was probably "for the best," since the lists of such competitions themselves were subject to "serious analysis."
Former Rector Igor Murog, a member of the Federation Council Committee on Science, Education and Culture, also generally approves of the idea of quoting budget places for Olympiads in order to "ensure a balanced approach to the recruitment of applicants and maintain equal opportunities for different categories of applicants." At the same time, he emphasizes the indisputable value of the Olympic movement as a tool for identifying talents.
"The point adjustments already being implemented by a number of leading universities, including reducing the list of Olympiads to be considered and setting a minimum confirmation score on the Unified State Exam, are perceived as a reasonable adaptation of the system to current conditions," the senator explained to Izvestia.
How do students choose between Olympiads and the Unified State Exam
For students who aspire to top highly competitive universities, admission through Olympiads is a basic scenario, said Arseniy Filin, founder of the Grand Exam online school. Because trying to enroll in such educational institutions only with the help of the Unified State Exam is a rather risky path.
— Schoolchildren and their parents from lyceums and gymnasiums, where children are initially focused on such prestigious universities, of course, know about this. Therefore, the whole class literally goes to the Olympics at different universities every weekend," the expert told Izvestia. — Such an eleventh-grader can seriously remember about preparing for the Unified State Exam only closer to April-May, when the main stream of Olympiads will be over.
The guys from ordinary schools are in a different situation: They may either underestimate the Olympic track, or they may not understand how to enter it, and they focus on the Unified State Exam.
Note that there are several levels of Olympiads in Russia. The All-Russian School Olympiad stands alone: it is the most massive and prestigious, it is held in 24 general education subjects, and several million students across the country participate in it at the school stage. But the right to enter without entrance exams is given only by success in the All-Russian stage of the Higher School of Economics.
There is also a list of other school Olympiads that are held in a wide variety of fields, from ordinary subjects to various fields such as robotics, economics, etc. In total, 83 list Olympiads have been approved in Russia in the academic year 2025-2026.
Arseniy Filin explains that there is a system for offsetting such competitions: you can successfully write an Olympiad at one university, and use the privilege when applying to another. This is possible due to the division of the Olympiads into three levels. Competitions of the highest level are accepted in almost all leading universities of the country.
— Olympiads often cause less stress for children than the Unified State Exam. The participants understand that even if they do not become winners in this particular Olympiad, they will gain experience, practice and will be able to try their hand at the next one," the source said.
However, cheating remains a problem at the Olympics. There is still no screening at some school competitions, and some of them are conducted in an online format. Arseniy Filin believes that the reduction in the list of eligible Olympiads by a number of leading universities is precisely due to the fight against cheating.
Which students are better: those who passed the BVI or the Unified State Exam
The leading universities in Russia emphasize that every Olympiad participant is usually a high-scoring student. Mikhail Gordin, Rector of the Bauman Moscow State Technical University, stressed that among those enrolled in the BVI this year, the average score for the Unified State Exam is only one point lower than that of those who passed the state exam.
However, Arseniy Filin notes that even a very talented student who perfectly solves complex Olympiad tasks and has deeper knowledge than the Unified State Exam requires is not always able to write an exam with 100 points.
— Firstly, the Unified State Exam requires maximum accuracy: you need to make no mistakes in calculations, not confuse anything and carefully perform a large number of sometimes banal tasks, — the expert draws attention. — Secondly, the criteria for evaluating tasks with a detailed answer to the Unified State Exam are much stricter, they are formalized as much as possible for the sake of uniformity of verification. At Olympiads, the criteria are more flexible: if an expert sees that a participant has understood the idea, solved the problem correctly, and only made a slight inaccuracy, they can receive only one or two points out of 10 or 15, and they will still become a prize-winner or a winner.
At the same time, students who have shown high results in a serious Olympiad of the first or second level, as a rule, do not need to prepare for the Unified State Exam separately, admits Arseniy Filin. It is enough just to practice: get used to the structure of the exam, develop a time allocation strategy, and carefully study the assessment criteria. As a rule, they already have knowledge of the material.
Dmitry Livanov told Izvestia that MIPT does not see much difference between those who entered according to the results of the Olympiad and those who passed the Unified State Exam.
— It's just two different ways of getting into universities and slightly different types of thinking. If the Unified State Exam is more about the ability to solve standardized, albeit complex tasks, then the Olympiads test the ability to think outside the box. Our experience shows that already in the second and third years there is no statistically significant difference between the academic performance of those and others," says the rector of MIPT.
In turn, Alexey Egorov said that the MEPhI National Research Nuclear University conducts an entrance rector's examination, in which, at the beginning of the year, the knowledge of computer science, mathematics, and physics is independently tested by incoming first-year students. And 80% of the first-year students who found themselves in the top 100 according to the results of this test are those who, in addition to a high score on the Unified State Exam, also have an award for any school Olympiad that gave the right to higher professional education.
Also, a large longitudinal study was conducted at the university under the leadership of Professor Elena Vesna, which compared the achievements of Olympic and non-Olympic athletes. The results are in favor of those who enrolled with the help of the Olympiad.
— In 125 university disciplines out of 140, the average score of Olympic athletes is higher than that of non-Olympic athletes. University-based Olympians have a more substantial portfolio than non-Olympic athletes. Olympians are more likely to go to research institutes and high-tech industries than non-Olympians. Among Olympic athletes, 19.97% of applicants are expelled from the university (for various reasons), among non—Olympic athletes — 26.37%, - Alexey Egorov lists the results of the study.
Therefore, he stressed, the university is interested in the participants of the Olympiads. Another thing is that it is important for other talented children to give way. There are other tools for this: this year, the National Research Nuclear University MEPhI decided to enroll more than a hundred students with an EXAM score of 272. They will study for free, but not at the expense of the state, but with money from MEPhI.
There are similar mechanisms in other universities. At ITMO University, for example, students who have distinguished themselves not by their results in Olympiads or the Unified State Exam, but by performing special projects, are separately enrolled. The university enters into a contract with them and pays for their education. These guys, like Olympic athletes, are appreciated for their ability to solve non-standard tasks, Vladimir Vasiliev emphasized.
Let's add that the number of university applicants based on the results of the Olympiads has been growing for several years in a row. Last year, according to the Ministry of Education and Science, the number of such applicants increased by 11% compared to 2024, to 9.46 thousand people.
Izvestia sent a request to the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation. No response had been received at the time of publication.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»