Avoiding the Reckoning: how private clinics profit from children with autism
The head of the Moscow clinic "PlanetaMed" Vasily Generalov, who found himself at the center of a scandal with a criminal case initiated under articles on causing serious harm to health through negligence and fraud, according to media reports, fled the country. The uproar arose after hundreds of families with children with autism complained about the treatment methods at this clinic. At PlaneteMed, autism spectrum disorders were treated with enemas, antiparasitic courses, testosterone, etc., which only led to a deterioration in the condition of children. Izvestia investigated how such a clinic appeared on the market and was able to work for a long time — about eight years — convincing people of its ability to cure autism.
Why did they open a criminal case?
At the end of July, the head of the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation, Alexander Bastrykin, instructed him to report on the investigation of a criminal case initiated after complaints from patients of the Moscow private clinic PlanetaMed. Hundreds of families have filed claims with the medical institution in connection with questionable methods of treating autism and the deterioration of children's condition after therapy. A criminal case was opened under Article 118 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation ("Causing serious harm to health by negligence") and Article 159 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation ("Fraud").
The media reported that Vasily Generalov and his clinic assumed during treatment that mental problems in children were allegedly caused by parasites: patients were cleansed of worms, injected with stem cells and prescribed hormones.
The mother of one of the patients said that her son was treated with antiparasitic drugs and he got worse — they only "rolled back the development" of the child.
Another girl had been given enemas with sodium chloride solution and prescribed hormones for more than a year, and the child could no longer go to the toilet on his own. Another small patient, according to his parents, was injected with stem cells worth 650 thousand rubles, after which he became hyperactive and stopped responding to treatment altogether.
Psychiatrist Stepan Krasnoshchekov was one of the first to draw attention to the PlanetaMed clinic, who criticized Vasily Generalov's methods in his blog in 2024. The head of the medical institution responded to the claims for some time, explaining it as "a campaign by followers of the American method of treating autism — ABA therapy," but in 2026 he stopped responding. At the same time, before the first public claims appeared, he made quite aggressive criticism of his fellow doctors and appeared on federal television as an expert.
And last Sunday, shortly after the information about the initiation of criminal cases, it became known that Vasily Generalov had disappeared — apparently, he had left Russia.
The PlanetaMed Clinic specializes not only in the treatment of autism, but also deals with the problems of epilepsy, multiple sclerosis and other diseases. It also has a branch in Samara. According to Rusprofile, the revenue of Medline LLC, which operates under the PlanetaMed brand, amounted to 86 million rubles in 2025 and 88 million rubles in 2024. The company's financial performance increased sharply two years ago, before that, the jump occurred in 2022 to 17 million from 7 million a year earlier. At the same time, Generalov began to study autism around 2018.
Why were Generalov's actions called fraud
Generalov called autism encephalitis of mixed etiology in social networks, which develops in an immunocomprehended child against the background of undifferentiated mitochondrial pathology. On this basis, he promised to cure the children completely. The media reported that the total cost of treatment reached about 12 million rubles.
The modern scientific approach is based on the fact that autism is incurable. Elena Bagaradnikova, a member of the board of the NGO Kontakt, a member of the board of the alliance "The Value of Everyone", stressed that an autistic child, like any other, may have epilepsy, sleep disorders, anxiety disorder, ADHD, endocrine disorders, parasitic infection, etc. But all these should be treated as separate diseases, and not declared the alleged "cause of autism."
"Russian clinical guidelines indicate that there is insufficient evidence of the efficacy and safety of stem cells, micropolarization, and a number of other interventions in ASD," she told Izvestia. — The basis of the assistance consists of individually selected educational, psychological, behavioral and communication interventions, as well as treatment of confirmed concomitant diseases.
Meanwhile, Stepan Krasnoshchekov noted that autism spectrum disorder is such that patients primarily need the help not of a doctor, but of a teacher, behavioral therapist, speech pathologist, speech therapist, etc. That is, people who help people with ASD not to recover from autism, but to live in society.
"However, in our mentality we call this disorder a disease, and parents are looking for treatment," he explained in an interview with Izvestia. — But we can't do anything about the main symptoms of autism. There have been a lot of studies, studies of mechanisms and methods of treatment: everything has been tried, everything has been tested, and nothing works. We are trying to explain this to people, and in general, the information is working: the situation is much better now than it was five years ago. But there is still a lot of work ahead.
Against this background, there are a lot of very different specialists who, either by their own delusion or by malicious intent, are trying to cash in on the "treatment" of ASD.
— Unfortunately, there are many clinics that offer such alternative treatment methods. It is difficult to say whether they are deliberately deceiving or not, because I know many doctors who really believe in the effectiveness of their actions," the psychiatrist pointed out. "The main problem with the Generalov clinic was that they prescribed a lot of unnecessary medications that are not just useless, but can actually be harmful.
Autism is becoming a particularly convenient target for unscrupulous offers, since after diagnosis, the family is often in a state of shock and is afraid to miss the "window of opportunity", and an honest specialist cannot promise a quick and guaranteed result, Elena Bagaradnikova added.
— At the same time, the child's development is uneven: new skills may appear naturally or through classes, but coincide in time with ivs, diet or dietary supplements. Then the improvement is mistakenly attributed to the last procedure. The marketing of hope works well on this, backed up by complex vocabulary about immunity, mitochondria, microbiota and toxins," she explained.
According to the expert, this problem is very common not only in Russia, but also abroad. According to a 2017 international survey, between 28 and 95% of families raising children with autism used alternative treatment methods, depending on the country. On average, this is every second family in the world.
— This includes relatively harmless practices, so these figures cannot be considered fraud statistics. But they give a general idea of the scale of the disaster," Elena Bagaradnikova pointed out.
However, she stressed that the very word "alternative" does not mean "fraudulent" at all. Music, horse riding, sports, or art classes can also be considered alternative practices — but it is important that they should not be marketed as a treatment for autism, attributed to an unproven medical effect, and offered instead of the necessary help.
But even this is not as scary as "experimental" methods based on dangerous treatment.
— The line runs not so much between "official" and "alternative" medicine, as between honestly informing the family and deliberately misleading it, — said the expert. — If the clinic knows that the effectiveness of the method has not been confirmed, and at the same time promises to "cure autism", "remove the diagnosis" or "restore the child", hides the risks and sells an expensive course — this can already be qualified as fraud.
The Izvestia interlocutor also noted that PlanetaMed positions itself as an integrative medicine clinic, but in fact it is not and discredits this approach to treatment.
—In good faith, this is a comprehensive view of the patient: coordinated work by specialists, attention not only to individual diagnoses, but also to concomitant diseases, nutrition, sleep, mental state, lifestyle and quality of life — while maintaining the principles of evidence—based medicine and standard diagnosis," the expert explained. — The integrative approach does not allow us to pass off a hypothesis as an established fact, and an unproven method as an effective treatment.
Why do such clinics operate in the market?
Yan Vlasov, co-chairman of the All-Russian Union of Public Associations of Patients, noted that it is important not to confuse truly experimental medicine with pseudomedicine.
"The law allows for clinical testing of new treatment methods, but it is carried out according to strict rules: with the participation of an expert council, subject to an approved program and state control," the source told Izvestia. — Any new method must undergo scientific verification and eventually receive recognition from the professional medical community. Today, there are registries and databases of clinical trials that can be used to understand whether a particular approach has been studied.
The patient should consciously participate in clinical testing, realizing that the effectiveness of the method is still being studied. However, such clinics often sell hope to a person who is in a difficult life situation for a lot of money.
— Such stories are especially painful when it comes to parents of children with serious illnesses. They are ready to look for any opportunity to help their child. They often sell property, take out loans, and spend their last savings. Using this condition for commercial gain is not just a violation of professional ethics. This is an exploitation of human despair," Yan Vlasov emphasized.
He added that it is important for the patient to pay attention to several basic things: the clinic must have a valid license for the type of medical activity that it provides; the patient must provide a clear contract, a detailed treatment plan, information about the cost of each stage and provide informed voluntary consent.
— If, instead of a medical justification, they offer to believe in the "author's method", promise a guaranteed cure, or are not ready to explain in writing why a particular procedure is prescribed, this is a serious reason to be wary, — the expert drew attention.
According to him, it is important to improve the control of such practices, as well as to improve the medical literacy of patients.
In turn, Konstantin Smirnov, an expert of the Popular Front, recommended that if a patient encounters fraud in providing medical care, contact the territorial body of Roszdravnadzor. They are required to register the complaint and help.
It should be noted that Roszdravnadzor is the main state controller of healthcare institutions, including private ones. He issues licenses for medical activities and can revoke them, as well as checks health facilities. But in fact, there is no strict control over treatment methods in Russia.
In a number of other countries, the advertising of therapy is stricter. For example, in the United States, the Federal Trade Commission may prosecute clinics for unfounded promises to "cure autism," in the EU, they also closely monitor the advertising of medicinal properties of stem cells, gene therapy, etc. However, the truth is that medical institutions that mislead patients still exist and thrive all over the world.
— Look at the story with Generalov: a criminal case was opened, but two years have passed since we started talking about it publicly, and before that he was actively involved in autism for another six years, — said Stepan Krasnoshchekov. — This is a very long time, eight years have passed in total! There were many people who were injured, who were unhappy, who wrote a statement to the police... But imagine: a family that has a child with autism, after ineffective and dangerous treatment, is forced to work to correct the deterioration of the condition. It's hard both financially and mentally. We simply don't have the time and energy to prove anything to the police and the prosecutor's office.
The current story, according to the psychiatrist, became public simply because a very large number of families faced problems, that is, a huge human resource was needed.
— It is very difficult to hold someone accountable, and the organizers of such clinics know this, and therefore they are still on the market. There are clinics that are 20-30 years old, and they continue to work without listening to the arguments of the other side," Stepan Krasnoshchekov said.
Izvestia sent inquiries to the PlanetaMed clinic, the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation and Roszdravnadzor. No responses had been received at the time of publication.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»