The last chance to save the USSR: what really happened in August 1991
Thirty-five years ago, in August 1991, events took place in the USSR that marked a turning point in the country's history. The attempt by members of the Emergency Committee to stop the reforms and remove Mikhail Gorbachev from power led to mass protests in Moscow and an open confrontation at the White House, which lasted from August 19 to 21. These three days determined the fate of the Soviet Union and went down in history as the August coup. Read about how the events unfolded and what they led to in the Izvestia article.
Why did the August coup arise and who joined the Emergency Committee?
By the early 1990s, the Soviet Union was in a deep systemic crisis. The economy was rapidly deteriorating, deficits and inflation were increasing, and the political system was losing its manageability. At the same time, the so—called sovereignty parade was growing in the Union republics - the regional elites demanded more and more independence, right up to secession from the USSR. These processes threatened the existence of the State in its former form.
One of the key attempts to save the country was the "Novoogarevsky process" — negotiations between the leadership of the USSR and the republics on a new format of the Union, initiated by Mikhail Gorbachev. The reform envisioned the creation of a renewed state — in fact, a confederation with broad powers of the republics. Thus, Gorbachev wanted to maintain a delicate balance between reformers and conservatives and respect the interests of the center in the face of increasing demands from the republics.
The negotiations took place at the residence of the President of the USSR in Novo-Ogaryovo near Moscow in the spring and summer of 1991. They were attended by the leaders of nine republics (excluding the three Baltic republics, Armenia, Georgia and Moldova) and the President of the USSR. The result was an agreement that journalists called "9 +1", which consolidated the intention to create a Union of Sovereign States. The document was supposed to replace the 1922 treaty on the formation of the USSR and become the foundation of a renewed state education.
The draft agreement was published on August 15, 1991 in the newspaper Pravda. Its signing was scheduled for August 20. However, Gorbachev's plans met fierce resistance from the conservative part of the party and state elite. They perceived the new Union Treaty as a direct threat to the existence of a single state and their power.
Representatives of the conservative part of the Union leadership feared that the new treaty would lead to a sharp weakening of the central government, the collapse of the USSR and the loss of their political influence. On August 18, 1991, a group of conspirators flew to Crimea, where the President of the USSR was on vacation at the state dacha in Foros, to try to convince him to declare a state of emergency. Gorbachev categorically refused.
On the night of August 18-19, the State Committee for the State of Emergency in the USSR (GKChP) was formed. It included key figures of the country's top leadership: Soviet Vice President Gennady Yanaev, Prime Minister Valentin Pavlov, Defense Minister Dmitry Yazov, Interior Minister Boris Pugo, KGB Chairman Vladimir Kryuchkov, First Deputy Chairman of the Defense Council Oleg Baklanov, Chairman of the Peasant Union Vasily Starodubtsev and President of the Association of State Enterprises Alexander Tizyakov.
Although Yanaev was declared the formal leader of the Emergency Committee, KGB Chairman Vladimir Kryuchkov became the key figure and the main organizer of the failed coup. The indictment in the GKCHP case states that Kryuchkov and the above-mentioned individuals "agreed to begin implementing plans to seize power on August 18, 1991," and to take "priority political, economic and legal measures in this regard."
The committee members themselves explained their actions by their desire to preserve the USSR, prevent chaos and restore control of the central government in the country.
How events unfolded in Moscow from August 19 to August 21, 1991
On the morning of August 19, 1991, Soviet citizens learned of the state of emergency. On radio and television, where the ballet "Swan Lake" was playing from morning to evening, the statement of the Emergency Committee was read out that Mikhail Gorbachev "cannot perform his duties for health reasons" and his powers are transferred to Vice-president Gennady Yanaev. It is precisely because of this combination that the ballet, as well as the subsequent demolition of the monument to Felix Dzerzhinsky on Lubyanka Square, has firmly entered the historical memory as one of the symbols of those events.
By order of Defense Minister Dmitry Yazov, troops were deployed to the capital: the Taman Motorized Rifle Division, the Kantemirovskaya Tank Division and the Tula Airborne Division. Columns of tanks and armored vehicles occupied key positions in the city center, including Manezhnaya Square and the approaches to the White House, the building of the Supreme Soviet of the RSFSR (now the Government House of the Russian Federation).
At the same time, the Emergency Committee banned rallies, restricted the activities of the media and tried to take control of the information space. Of the central print media, only nine publications received permission to publish, including Izvestia, which published operational reports.
However, the development of events turned out to be exactly the opposite of the conspirators' expectations. On the very first day, thousands of people began to gather at the White House. Among them were politicians, journalists and cultural figures. Cellist Mstislav Rostropovich, actress Margarita Terekhova, actor Boris Khmelnitsky, Vice Mayor of Moscow Yuri Luzhkov and former USSR Foreign Minister Eduard Shevardnadze defended the White House.
Thousands of citizens gathered at the White House, many of whom had just returned from vacation, and the construction of improvised barricades began. The number of people gathered varied: according to various estimates, by the evening of August 20, tens of thousands of people were at the White House, some sources say up to 100-150 thousand. As one of the eyewitnesses recalled: "People went without appeals, they just understood that the fate of the country was being decided."
In Leningrad, thousands of people held rallies on St. Isaac's Square. Protest actions also swept other major cities of the country — Nizhny Novgorod, Sverdlovsk (now Yekaterinburg), Novosibirsk, Tyumen.
The confrontation culminated on the night of August 20-21. In Moscow, clashes occurred near the tunnel on the Garden Ring, as a result of which three people were killed — Dmitry Komar, Ilya Krichevsky and Vladimir Usov, who tried to stop armored vehicles.
On the morning of August 21, Defense Minister Yazov ordered the withdrawal of troops from Moscow. After the coup failed, representatives of the Emergency Committee flew to Foros, but Gorbachev refused to cooperate with them. On the same day, the activities of the Emergency Committee actually stopped.
The role of Gorbachev and Yeltsin in the days of the coup
Mikhail Gorbachev was in Foros, Crimea, when the coup began. According to the official version of the Emergency Committee, he was "incapacitated," but later it turned out that the president of the USSR was actually isolated and deprived of communication. Gorbachev himself later stated: "They tried to force me to support the state of emergency, but I refused."
Meanwhile, the President of the RSFSR, Boris Yeltsin, assumed a key role in Moscow. On August 19, he arrived at the White House and addressed the citizens. It was then that his famous speech from a tank was heard, which became one of the symbols of resistance to the coup. Yeltsin called for disobeying the Emergency Committee and declared the committee's actions an unconstitutional coup.
This speech played a huge role in mobilizing society. As the media later wrote, the image of Yeltsin on a tank was perceived as one of the brightest embodiments of the GKCHP resistance and became as textbook as the image of Lenin on an armored car in 1917.
Subsequently, the first president of Russia issued decrees on the reassignment of a number of union executive authorities to the Russian leadership. Yeltsin also dismissed many high-ranking officials who supported the coup and announced that all participants in the Emergency Committee would be held accountable.
Gorbachev returned to Moscow only on August 22, after the failed coup. However, his political positions were already seriously weakened. Real power gradually passed to the Russian leadership led by Yeltsin.
Why did the coup attempt fail
The failure of the Emergency Committee, despite the fact that it had an army in its hands, is explained by a number of reasons. First of all, the conspirators were not ready for the large-scale and determined resistance led by Boris Yeltsin. They underestimated the political will and charisma of the President of the RSFSR, as well as his ability to mobilize the masses.
The indecision of the coup organizers also played a key role. Despite the introduction of troops, the Emergency Committee has not decided to forcefully disperse the protesters. Moreover, some military units refused to follow orders, and some commanders openly sided with the Russian leadership.
As the participants of the events themselves later admitted, the putschists did not have a clear plan. Decisions were made late, and actions were not coordinated. At the same time, the self—proclaimed Emergency Committee was unable to offer society an understandable alternative, either political or economic.
Public reaction also played an important role. A significant part of the citizens did not support the attempt to return to a rigid centralized system. Mass protests in Moscow have shown the willingness of people to defend their freedom by opposing the use of force.
On August 21, it became obvious that the coup attempt had failed. Members of the Emergency Committee began to leave the capital, some of them were arrested. Interior Minister Boris Pugo, without waiting for them to come for him, committed suicide on August 22, 1991.
How the August coup affected the collapse of the USSR
Paradoxically, the attempt to "save the USSR" undertaken by the Emergency Committee led to exactly the opposite results, dramatically changing the balance of political forces. The August events led to the fact that the activities of the CPSU were first suspended, and then completely banned on the territory of the RSFSR.
In the coming weeks, the rapid process of disintegration of the state began. The republican authorities declared independence one after another, and the allied structures lost control of the situation. In December 1991, the Belovezhskaya Agreement was signed, which legally fixed the termination of the existence of the USSR.
Subsequently, Gorbachev called the consequences of the coup catastrophic and placed considerable responsibility on its organizers. At the same time, historians are still arguing about whether the coup was a chance to save the Soviet Union or only accelerated its disintegration. However, it is obvious that August 1991 was a turning point, after which a return to the previous system proved impossible.
According to a VTsIOM survey conducted on the 30th anniversary of the August events, Russians' assessments of the coup remain mixed. Among those who heard about the events of August 1991, 47% called them an episode of the struggle for power in the country's top leadership, 31% — a tragic event with grave consequences for the country, and 7% — the victory of the democratic revolution, which ended the power of the CPSU. In addition, 41% of respondents believed that the participants in the Emergency Committee sought to preserve the USSR, while 38% believed that they pursued primarily personal political goals.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»