Food doesn't come alone: how to stop counterfeit supplies to schools
At a meeting of the Rosselkhoznadzor Public Council, the Rosselkhoznadzor came up with new initiatives in the field of social nutrition: the agency proposed to tighten the system of public procurement of products for schools, kindergartens and hospitals, as a lot of unsafe food gets there. Among the measures, in particular, a ban on participation in tenders for organizations that had previously been caught supplying counterfeit goods, and inspections of supplier companies using tracking systems before concluding contracts, rather than after. Whether these initiatives, if implemented, will help solve the problems of the social nutrition market, read the Izvestia article.
How much counterfeit gets into schools
At the meeting, representatives of the Rosselkhoznadzor provided monitoring data on social nutrition for 2025, according to which violations in terms of food quality and safety were recorded at 27% of suppliers. In the first half of 2026, 2.4 thousand samples were examined, and inconsistencies were found in 405 of them. The highest percentage of violations was found in dairy and meat products — 20.9% and 15.1%, respectively.
The main types of violations listed by the Rosselkhoznadzor are changes in expiration dates, the delivery of products without information about raw materials, the discovery of goods that have not passed all safety confirmation procedures, with a violation of traceability.
Sergey Maslov, vice President of the Institute of Industrial Nutrition, told Izvestia that thousands of food studies provide an opportunity to assess the situation, but do not allow it to "radically change." Moreover, according to these data, it is not possible to draw a conclusion about the proportion of dangerous products that were eventually seized and did not end up on the plate.
"Often, while the research is being conducted, the products continue to be used,— he noted.
The Rosselkhoznadzor has made proposals to improve the safety of food that ends up in children's and social institutions.
Checking suppliers before, not after
The first of the announced measures is to analyze the activities of business entities in the Mercury, Vesta, and Cerberus components of the FGIS VetIS when concluding contracts for the supply of food. That is, to check their work before signing the documents.
Currently, all suppliers have to work in the Mercury system anyway, making out veterinary accompanying documents (VSD). Upon acceptance of the goods, schools and other social institutions must extinguish the VSD in Mercury, confirming the receipt of the products. But there is no actual verification of the conformity of the product content with the information in the certificate: the customer has neither the competencies nor the equipment for this. As a result, cancellation often takes place formally: the employee of the canteen accepts the received goods, and often he has no other choice, because in any case the children need to be fed, it is impossible to disrupt the food. This is often used by unscrupulous companies that supply counterfeit goods with vegetable fats instead of dairy, one type of meat instead of another, and a broken label with a suitable expiration date.
At the same time, at the stage of selecting a supplier and concluding a contract, no in-depth analysis of the company's activities is carried out for all components of VETIS. The key parameters are the proposed price, compliance with documentation, and availability in the register of bona fide suppliers. They don't look at the history of violations, the volume of product returns, or inconsistencies in Rosselkhoznadzor systems.
The agency, therefore, proposes to introduce a mandatory analysis of a potential supplier at the stage before the conclusion of the contract: whether the traceability of the Mercury product is respected, how laboratory tests are conducted on Vesta, and whether there are necessary permits to work with Cerberus products. So far, this is only a proposal, and it has not yet been detailed.
The expert of the direction "Popular Front. Analytics, a member of the working group of the State Council of the Russian Federation in the field of Agriculture, Sergey Sokolov, noted that now suppliers are being analyzed whenever possible: a survey is being conducted, the availability of their own production base is assessed not only for preparation, but also for ingredients, history and business reputation are being studied.
"It is quite logical to make such a preliminary selection systematic — it will be useful and will eliminate subjectivity in the assessments of candidates," he told Izvestia.
Lyudmila Manitskaya, Chairman of the Rosselkhoznadzor Public Council and director of the Dairy Union of Russia, added that the control system is now responding to detected violations, and a modern approach should be to prevent the problem. She is sure that all the technical capabilities for the preliminary assessment of suppliers are already there, it is only important to use them correctly when making decisions.
— We are not talking about creating additional barriers for business. It's about getting companies that are really responsible for product quality into the social supply market," she said.
Sergey Maslov, however, noted that it is pointless to analyze the quality of a product that has not yet been delivered or even produced.
— Check the samples? But everyone's samples will match, it has nothing to do with the quality of the actual delivery. With regard to the supply of products, the only way to ensure quality is to conduct expert examinations of the supplied goods," the source stressed.
Do not accept counterfeit
The second measure proposed by the Rosselkhoznadzor is to "exclude the possibility of shipments of controlled goods to social institutions for which the Mercury component lacks comprehensive traceability data based on veterinary certification." In other words, to impose a ban on the admission to schools, kindergartens and social institutions of products for which there is no complete and understandable history of origin in the Mercury system.
Sergey Maslov recalled that 44-FZ on the contract system already provides for the conduct of examinations of purchased goods, both with and without the involvement of expert organizations.
— But today (unreasonably in relation to food products), customers everywhere apply the right to produce it "on their own". The requirements for the examination of products, as well as the very concept of "examination of food products for delivery to social institutions", are not defined. In our opinion, the definition and requirement to carry out an examination of food products when supplied to social institutions using laboratory tests can be established at the level of the government or the Ministry of Agriculture of Russia," he said.
The expert added that social institutions cannot physically carry out an examination of food products on their own. However, it is very important to do this: without laboratory tests, it is impossible to check products for microbiology, adulteration, etc.
The editorial interlocutor called the organization of supplies through distribution and logistics centers the most effective way to introduce a system of mandatory product expertise in social nutrition. There are already such centers, in particular, in Vologda and Samara: the centers accept products, carry out entrance quality control and transport assembled batches of different goods to each institution. There is a similar system in Moscow.: Laboratory control of all groups of goods supplied to catering facilities is carried out there. The actual cost is 72 million rubles per year or 0.22 rubles per person per day, while the cost of meals in schools is about 140 rubles. At the same time, both the supervisory authorities and the customer receive information about the results of laboratory control.
— The number of counterfeit shipments detected directly depends on the degree of centralization of food purchases in social nutrition. There is practically no falsification in regions with a high degree of centralization: Tatarstan, St. Petersburg, Moscow, Krasnodar Krai. Moreover, in these conditions, the share of local products is growing significantly, and cases of falsification are most common in shipments from other regions with repeated changes in the ownership of products," said Sergey Maslov.
New blacklist of suppliers
The third proposed measure is to provide for a ban on participation in deliveries to social institutions for organizations that have previously participated in the circulation of counterfeit and counterfeit goods. In fact, it is proposed to introduce a blacklist of such organizations.
However, there is already a register of unscrupulous suppliers under the law on public procurement. Apparently, the Rosselkhoznadzor proposes to expand it and create it separately specifically for social nutrition. The official blacklist for public procurement includes companies and sole proprietors who seriously violated the rules of tenders. Decisions on inclusion in the register are made by the Federal Antimonopoly Service, the presence of unscrupulous suppliers there is not indefinite — two years, after that you can return to the market.
At the same time, the counterfeit supplied to the school may already be the reason for the company to be sent to the existing blacklist, but for this the customer must contact the FAS and prove that the terms of the public procurement were violated. Sergey Maslov noted that in this sense, the register of unscrupulous suppliers under 44-FZ and 223-FZ is sufficient. Moreover, the position of the Ministry of Finance and the Federal Antimonopoly Service on this issue has been unchanged for many years: just add such suppliers to the existing list, and then you will not have to keep additional ones.
Why are these measures not enough
In general, the Rosselkhoznadzor stated that the sphere of social nutrition "is actually a separate industry and requires separate independent regulation." Lyudmila Manitskaya called the proposed measures "absolutely the right direction."
"A simple principle should apply: if a product goes to the table for a child or a patient, we must understand its entire history — where it came from, who produced it, and how it ended up in the institution," she told Izvestia. — Mercury, Vesta, and Cerberus are real systems that allow you to see the movement of products. In fact, this is the digital footprint of the product. And a product without a history is like a person without a passport.
In her opinion, a conscientious manufacturer will only benefit from such measures, because now he has to compete not only with those who know how to produce well, but also with those who just know how to draw up documents well.
Sergey Maslov, in turn, believes that these measures are not enough.
"Only a systematic approach and drastic measures will make it possible to put into practice the principles of guaranteed food safety in social nutrition," he said.
The expert also stressed that he shares the Rosselkhoznadzor's position on the need for "separate independent regulation" of the industry. According to him, social nutrition should aim not to reduce the supply of counterfeit products, but to ensure the guaranteed safety of the supplied food products. And for this, it is necessary to consider social nutrition as a separate branch of the economy with its own regulatory framework.
Tatyana Butskaya, First deputy chairman of the State Duma Committee on Family Protection, Fatherhood, Motherhood and Childhood, stressed that this requires the adoption of a federal law "On the basics of providing and organizing social nutrition in the Russian Federation."
"The draft law has already been developed, it was supported by the legislative bodies of 73% of the subjects of the Russian Federation," she told Izvestia, agreeing with Sergey Maslov that the proposed decisions of the public council are not enough.
Both Tatiana Butskaya and Sergey Maslov spoke in favor of increasing the level of responsibility for food safety. Until now, the school principal remains the main one, and in most cases the only one responsible for organizing, providing, monitoring and solving nutrition problems. At the same time, he has neither the financial resources nor the appropriate specialists for this. As a result, Rospotrebnadzor imposes thousands of fines worth millions of rubles on schools. Although back in 2019, Russian President Vladimir Putin called for "detaching nutrition control in schools from the school itself and increasing responsibility."
"As long as the founders are not fully responsible for food safety, the state of affairs will not change," said Sergey Maslov and called on the Rosselkhoznadzor administration to bring the founders of organizations to administrative responsibility when cases of acceptance of dangerous food products for children's nutrition are identified.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»