The Hour of reckoning: Europe is mired in record debts
The EU countries are living beyond their means. The national debt of the 27 EU states rose to a record €15.7 trillion in the first quarter, according to Eurostat data. In France, Italy and Germany, debt has updated historical highs. But Europe doesn't seem to be going to stop: the economy is stagnating, and defense spending continues to grow. The previous major debt crisis nearly split the eurozone and forced several countries to ask for multibillion-dollar aid. Why Europe is climbing into debt again and how it could turn out for Russia — in the Izvestia article.
Life on loan
In the first quarter of this year, the EU's total public debt increased by €327 billion and reached its highest level since 1994. Debt increased the most in France — by 75.6 billion euros at once, to a record 3.5 trillion euros. This already significantly exceeds the country's GDP.
Moreover, Paris began to accumulate debts especially actively under Emmanuel Macron — in nine years their volume increased by almost 60%, or about € 1.3 trillion. And this amount continues to grow. According to the calculations of the authorities, Paris will spend €64.8 billion in 2026 on debt servicing alone, and €74.2 billion next year.
Italy is next. During the quarter, its debt increased by another €62 billion, to €3.158 trillion. In terms of the size of the economy, Rome's situation is even more difficult than France's: debt reached 138.9% of GDP. Only Greece has a higher rate — 143.5%. The list of countries where the state owes more than the entire economy produces in a year also includes Belgium and Spain.
Germany closes the top three in terms of absolute debt. Its liabilities increased by almost €64 billion in the quarter, to €2.9 trillion. So far, Berlin's debt burden is significantly lower — 64.4% of GDP. However, now it can start to grow faster. Last year, Parliament eased the so-called "debt brake," removing a significant portion of defense and security spending from borrowing restrictions. Berlin will need a lot of money: only the budget of the Ministry of Defense in 2027 is planned to increase to €109.7 billion (instead of the current €82 billion)
The problem has been recognized in Brussels for several years. "We must also recognize the new reality of higher public debt," said European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen back in 2022. She later called for reducing high debt levels in a "realistic, gradual and sustainable manner." However, the situation has only gotten worse since then.
At the same time, Brussels is calling on the most problematic countries to tighten their belts. For example, France has been ordered to reduce its excessive budget deficit by 2029. But at the same time, the EU allows states to deviate from budget constraints in favor of increasing military spending.
On a grand scale
This has already happened in Europe. The first signs of the last debt crisis appeared back in 2009 in Greece, and already in 2010, problems gripped several eurozone countries at once. Financial assistance was also needed by Ireland, Portugal, Spain, and Cyprus. At some point, even Greece's continued membership in the euro zone was in question. Athens withdrew from the latest financial assistance program only in August 2018.
The current debt increase has other reasons. The EU is going through one crisis after another. At first, during the pandemic, governments flooded the economy with money, supporting businesses and the public. In 2020 alone, the EU's total public debt jumped from 77.5% to 90.7% of GDP.
As soon as Europe began to move away from the pandemic, the energy crisis followed. After a sharp reduction in Russian gas supplies, energy prices soared, and governments reopened their wallets. Anti-crisis subsidies cost Brussels €187 billion in 2022 and another €145 billion in 2023, according to the EU website.
At the same time, Europe lost one of the key advantages on which its industry had been based for decades — relatively cheap energy resources. This was especially painful for Germany. The problems are noticeable in the automotive industry. Mercedes-Benz is expanding production in cheaper Hungary, and Volkswagen is preparing to reduce the model range. Even more significant is the concern's plant in Osnabrück, where production of machines is scheduled to cease in 2027. Now the site is being considered to accommodate the capacities of the Israeli defense company Rafael.
Military actions in the Middle East have hit energy prices again. "The conflict in the Middle East has a severe impact on fossil fuel prices, slows down growth and directly affects the lives of citizens and companies," admitted the head of the European Council, Antonio Costa, after the April EU summit in Cyprus.
However, Brussels is not going to review its spending plans. On the contrary, the European Union is launching a new cycle of large-scale spending. The ReArm Europe plan assumes the mobilization of up to €800 billion for defense needs, and a significant part of this money should be found by the states themselves, including through new borrowings.
Financing of Ukraine continues in parallel. For example, Germany has provided or reserved about €55.5 billion in military aid to Kiev in four years. And at the July NATO summit, the allies pledged to provide Ukraine with €70 billion in military aid and equipment this year and maintain at least a comparable level of support next year.
How will it end
The first to feel a further increase in debt will be countries that have had chronic budget deficits for years. Experts primarily name France and Italy as the most at risk.
— In Italy, the risk is associated with a very high debt burden and low growth potential, in France — with a rapidly deteriorating budget trajectory, — says Yuri Mishukov, director of the investment department of NPF GAZFOND Pension Savings.
At the same time, a huge debt in itself does not mean an inevitable default. Even the situation of Greece today is different from the situation of the early 2010s: a significant part of its obligations are stretched over long periods and serviced on preferential terms.
However, if the European national debt continues to grow at the current rate, an increasing part of budget revenues will be directed not to economic development, infrastructure and support for the population, but to interest payments, says Artur Leer, president of the Association of Exporters and Importers.
— This may lead to higher taxes, cuts in social spending and investments, as well as an increased debt burden on the most problematic countries. While maintaining weak economic growth, Europe risks facing prolonged stagnation, a deepening gap between EU states and new debt crises, the expert warns.
Most likely, the new debt crisis in Europe will not reach Russia directly. In recent years, financial ties have significantly decreased, and Russian foreign trade has shifted to other markets. However, it is impossible to completely isolate oneself from the consequences.
— The main risk is associated with a possible decline in global demand and prices for raw materials. At the same time, the direct financial channel for the Russian economy is limited today, so the consequences are likely to be transmitted through oil quotes, trading partners and the general volatility of world markets," Mishukov believes.
The rail allows for another scenario. According to him, the more serious the internal economic problems of the European Union become, the stronger the demand for a review of the current foreign economic policy may grow. In the long run, this may encourage individual European countries to try to restore some of their lost trade ties with Russia.
"In this case, Russian companies will be able to regain part of the traditional market, while not abandoning the further development of relations with countries in Asia, the Middle East, Africa and other regions," the analyst concludes.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»