Non-child fears: what is the reality of underfunding school security
In 2025, the volume of public procurement of security services for educational institutions in Russia increased almost one and a half times, to 86 billion rubles, according to data from the Tenderplan tender management system. However, such a significant increase cannot fully reflect the situation in school security: firstly, the figures themselves must be treated with caution, because it is impossible to take into account many nuances when calculating. And secondly, in fact, many contracts for the security of a particular institution remain very highly underfunded. In fact, the cost reduction is carried out either by customers at the stage of submitting applications, or by dumping market participants at the bidding stage. Izvestia investigated how underfunded the safety of Russian schoolchildren is in reality.
How the security market in schools has grown
A significant increase in the cost of protecting educational institutions was shown by an analysis by Tenderplan, conducted at the request of Izvestia. It turned out that in 2024, according to 44-FZ, 11.6 thousand competitive tenders were held in the amount of 52.4 billion rubles and 3.4 thousand purchases from a single supplier in the amount of 3.5 billion rubles. In 2025, there was an increase in both 44-FZ (13.8 thousand tenders worth 82 billion rubles) and purchases from a single supplier (3.6 thousand tenders worth 4.1 billion rubles).
"The main increase is provided by competitive procurement, which may indicate an increase in security requirements and an expansion of the contract base in the field of school security," Tenderplan told Izvestia.
However, data on the total volume of the security services market should be treated with some caution. Tenderplan explained that the sample was created using specially customized search keys and exceptions, which analysts prepared for each individual query. For the former, a small number of not-quite-relevant purchases may be included in the list. And given the size of the market, it is impossible to thoroughly check the entire list. There are also nuances related to the specifics of public procurement, when, for example, the exact subject of the purchase is indicated not in the name, but in the documentation. Therefore, the company calls the figures "as close as possible to the real ones, but with an error."
It should also be borne in mind that in a number of regions, security services are funded for longer periods — for example, three-year contracts were concluded in Moscow until 2025, which, of course, were not reflected in the data for 2024.
Sergey Silivonchik, Chairman of the Board of the Union of Self-Regulatory Organizations in the Non-Governmental Security Sector, vice-president of the SRO Association School without Danger, expressed surprise at such a sharp increase in the volume of purchases in an interview with Izvestia. However, he stressed that there really should be a certain increase in spending on the protection of educational institutions.
— There are objective reasons for this: inflation, changes in tax policy, an increase in the minimum wage, the fight against dumping, shadow employment, in some regions — bringing the initial maximum contract price (NMCC) to regulatory values, etc., — he explained.
How market participants dump
It is interesting to analyze the Tenderplan study from the point of view of a drop in the final contract value relative to the initial maximum price that the customer offers to market participants.
In 2024, the total price drop as a result of bidding was about 13%, that is, on average, it was by this proportion that the auction participants reduced the cost of services. The share of contracts without price reduction was about 29%. A decrease in the range from 1 to 20% occurred in 19.5% of cases. The share of deep dumping (over 41%) in 2024 was about 11.5%, while approximately 3% of contracts were underestimated by 61% or more.
In 2025, as the figures show, little has changed — the average price drop was 12.4%, but the total share of deep dumping decreased by 3.3% to 8.1% of the total number of tenders.
In fact, the study shows that over 1,000 contracts are terminated annually with a sharp decrease of 41% or more.
On average, there are two or three participants in tenders. It is logical that the more suppliers there are in the auction, the higher the probability of dumping: the average price drop for two participants is about 18%, for four or more — over 35%.
Many companies literally specialize in dumping. For example, the Ufa company OOO CHOO Sokol has 98 wins in 98 tenders, the average price reduction relative to NMCC is 28.3%. The organization operates mainly in Tatarstan. OP Leader Yug LLC from the Krasnodar Territory boasts similar results (86 wins out of 86 with an average decrease of 23.8%).
Sergey Silivonchik explained that dumping in government procurement under 44-FZ is considered a reduction in the initial maximum contract price by 25% or more. It is the dumpers who form the main composition of suppliers of substandard services, he stressed. In this situation, a company that seeks to fulfill the contract in compliance with all legal requirements and make some profit will not be able to win the competition.
The main item in the cost of security services is the salary of employees, the expert recalled. A significant reduction in labor costs leads to the appearance of unskilled personnel in posts or to their absence altogether.
— As a result, there is a situation where some pretend to pay, others pretend to work, and budget money is wasted, and the task of ensuring the safety and security of the facility, as well as the people on it, is pushed into the background, — Sergey Silivonchik pointed out the problem.
What is hidden dumping?
If you believe only these figures, then the problem seems to concern a relatively small proportion of tenders: in two years, with a decrease in NMC of more than 25%, only 16% of contracts were terminated.
However, this actually applies to a much larger number of purchases. The fact is that dumping is almost always carried out where the initial maximum contract price was originally correctly calculated, in accordance with order No. 45 of the Russian Guard, where the formula for such calculations is clearly spelled out. If you delve into the documentation for each contract, you can see how the NMCC is artificially underestimated: having calculated one amount according to the formula, it is simply "knocked down" in accordance with the limits of budgetary obligations. That is, there is no money more than the budget allocated, and therefore the NMCC is reduced to this level.
For example, in June 2025, security services were purchased at the Deevskaya Secondary School in the Sverdlovsk region. According to NMCC calculations, the amount offered to the performers should have been 1.34 million rubles. However, due to budget limits, the initial maximum price was reduced to 789 thousand rubles. In fact, the amount was reduced by 41% without any dumping. Three companies took part in the auction, the total amount was 757.9 thousand rubles. Thus, the underestimation from calculations based on the order of the Rosgvardiya turned out to be at the level of 43%, although officially it was only 4%.
Sometimes the reduction of NMCC based on budget limits is reinforced by dumping agents. In particular, in Bataysk, Rostov region, in June 2025, 725.9 thousand rubles were allocated from the budget for the protection of preschool No. 7, although 1.3 million rubles were estimated. Three participants in the public procurement process aggravated the already serious (by 45%) reduction in the required amount. As a result, the winner received a contract for 591.6 thousand rubles. Officially, this is not dumping, but in reality, the amount required for kindergarten protection decreased by 55%.
— At the same time, with regard to the reduction of NMCC by customers using reducing coefficients, the Ministry of Finance has already commented on the situation: the cost of a unit of service should not change, the reduction of NMCC in case of budget deficit should affect the volume of purchases, — said Sergey Silivonchik.
Such actions by customers are based on a misinterpretation of the law, said Anatoly Vyborny, deputy chairman of the State Duma Committee on Security and Anti-Corruption.
— According to Article 6 of the Budget Code of the Russian Federation, the concept of "budget commitment limit" applies only to state-owned institutions. This term is not applicable to other forms of organizations," the parliamentarian noted. — In addition, there is no rule of law in Russian legislation that allows the customer to independently reduce the price of a unit of goods, work, or service. The Russian Ministry of Finance and the Prosecutor General's Office adhere to this position.
It is extremely difficult to estimate the volume of purchases in which a sharp decrease in the contract amount occurs at the tender application level: these data are embedded in the NMCC justification document. Moreover, the calculation is often not given in detail or is performed not at all by order of the Rosgvardiya, as it should be done, but at the average price on the market. The annual monitoring on the state of general education conducted by the Popular Front helps to partially understand the scale of the problem. Within its framework, principals of educational institutions are regularly asked to evaluate, among other things, the quality of security in schools.
— This year, 23% of directors admitted that they are forced to save money on ensuring the protection of an educational organization due to insufficient funding, — an expert from the Popular Front told Izvestia. Analytics" by Konstantin Smirnov. — In 2025, their share was 25%.
At the same time, according to the interlocutor of the editorial office, only 61% of educational organizations have security functions assigned to a licensed private security organization. Another 22% is just a watchman, 11% is a watchman, and 6% is a unit of the Russian Guard. To be fair, the share of schools with guards and watchmen has decreased significantly (from 34% and 13% in 2025, respectively) precisely in favor of public school services, which may explain the strong growth in the overall market.
In fact, two situations are often noticeable on contracts selectively analyzed by Izvestia in the regions: if the contract price decreases relative to the NMC by a small amount, this means that when calculating the NMC, it was cut due to budget commitment limits so much that even companies engaged in dumping cannot compete for this purchase. If the NMCC calculation remains correct, from five to nine companies take part in the competition, which eventually bring down the total amount very much.
Curiously, in both cases, the fight against dumpers will help: if the road to public procurement is blocked for them, no one will come to contracts with insufficient financial support, and more money will have to be allocated for protection. And professional responsible companies will be able to participate in contracts with a properly calculated NMCC.
— The best way out of this situation is to further develop the already well—established institute of self—regulation in the industry and the system of encouraging good faith, - Sergey Silivonchik is convinced.
At the same time, the first necessary measure is to increase transparency and control, Anatoly Vyborny emphasized.
— It is necessary to ensure maximum openness of all stages of tender procedures, publication of all documents and decisions, as well as to create independent bodies to control public procurement, which will verify the validity of prices and the quality of services, — he said.
The second measure is to achieve a realistic budget and calculate the NMCC in strict accordance with order 45 of the Rosgvardiya, and in the absence of budget funds in full, reduce the volume of services rather than their cost.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»