Experts called the regions' hasty plans to ban vapes
The introduction of bans on vaping at the regional level is hasty before a systemic decision is made at the federal level, says Maya Dubovik, Doctor of Economics, Professor of the Department of Economic Theory at Plekhanov Russian University of Economics.
In her opinion, such steps carry "significant risks for the country's single economic space, setting a precedent for its fragmentation." "The consequence of this decision is the flow of "prohibited" products from neighboring regions and the transition of legal turnover to shadow turnover, which contradicts the general logic of restrictions implemented at the regional level," Dubovik said.
A bill to completely ban the retail sale of vapes and electronic cigarettes was submitted to the legislative Assembly of the Ulyanovsk region at the end of March. In this region, along with the Penza Region and the Perm Territory, they are striving to implement bans on their own, justifying their necessity by the insufficiency of existing federal restrictions on the sale of nicotine-containing devices to minors.
At the same time, at the federal level, it is planned to grant regions the right to restrict the turnover of tobacco products within the framework of the draft law on licensing of retail and wholesale trade in tobacco that passed the first reading. The relevant amendments have been prepared for the second reading and have already been approved by the government commission.
As Kommersant previously reported, with reference to the office of Deputy Prime Minister Dmitry Grigorenko, who oversees the development of the document, the regions will receive the right to implement an experiment to limit the turnover of such products in the period from March 1, 2027 to March 1, 2032. Then, taking into account the evaluation of the effectiveness of the experimental results, a decision will be made on the need for further adjustment of regulation. In regions that do not exercise the right to impose a ban, the task will be solved by measures to license retail.
"The very fact of regional restrictions, in the absence of a comprehensive assessment and preliminary study, leads to significant turbulence within the business community," said Natalia Levoshich, PhD in Economics, Associate Professor of Logistics at the Faculty of Economics and Business at the Financial University under the Government of the Russian Federation, Director of the Center for Modern Financial Technologies at the Higher School of Public and Municipal Finance Management.
She stressed that both small-format trade entities and large chains in the region "are forced to urgently revise product matrices, often broadly interpreting restrictive norms." "At a distance, this can have a significant negative economic effect," Levosic added.
All important news is on the Izvestia channel in the MAX messenger.
Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»