Skip to main content
Advertisement
Live broadcast
Main slide
Beginning of the article
Озвучить текст
Select important
On
Off

The regions need to switch to a new procedure for calculating waste accumulation standards for residential buildings approved by the government by July 1, 2027. Now they are allowed to use the method of comparative analysis rather than measurements, the press service of the Russian Environmental Operator (REO) reports. Izvestia investigated how the new method of comparative analysis is simpler and more convenient for the regions, as well as how the transition to the new order will affect residents and waste removal tariffs.

Cost reduction

Previously, waste accumulation standards for residents were calculated only using measurements: specialists in the regions carried out seasonal MSW measurements, each of which lasted for seven days, and then based on these data, the final indicators were determined. This approach took a lot of time, the REO's press service told Izvestia.

"Now the key change is that the regions have been allowed to use the comparative analysis method. It is based on the formula: the base value is multiplied by a special coefficient calculated based on the results of research conducted by PPK REO," the operator's press service said.

мусор
Photo: TASS/Donat Sorokin

It is expected that the new approach will allow for more accurate consideration of the actual generation of waste, reduce the risk of regulatory distortion and make tariffs more equitable for residents.

Government Decree No. 241 does not introduce a new calculation method, but only expands the capabilities of the regions, allowing for unlimited use of the comparative analysis method in determining waste accumulation standards, the press service of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment told Izvestia.
"Previously, such calculation standards could only be applied temporarily — no more than 18 months, until the actual measurements were carried out. Now, comparative analysis can significantly speed up the process of approving standards, for example, if previous indicators have been canceled," the ministry said.

At the same time, the traditional method of measuring over four seasons remains, which gives regions more flexibility in choosing an approach. The relevance of the changes is related to the fact that by July 1, 2027, all regions must update the waste accumulation standards approved before the adoption of Resolution No. 1390 in 2023.

Work accuracy

The introduction of the comparative analysis method significantly simplifies the process of calculating waste accumulation standards for regions, Stanislav Guzhov, associate professor at the Faculty of Management at the Institute of Management of the Presidential Academy, told Izvestia. It was usually necessary to carry out large-scale field measurements in different types of residential buildings and in different seasons, which took a lot of time and required significant resources.

мусор
Photo: IZVESTIA/Andrey Erstrem

"The new approach allows us to rely on already calculated and approved indicators from other regions with comparable characteristics, such as population density, type of development, and level of socio-economic development," he said.

This not only reduces the administrative and financial burden, but also contributes to the formation of more uniform and transparent settlement rules throughout the country.

The transition to a new methodology, in his opinion, will lead to a revision of the current waste accumulation standards. In cases where they were previously overestimated due to inaccuracies or limited measurements, residents will have the opportunity to pay a fairer price for waste disposal, closer to the actual volume of MSW formation.

In general, the system will become more balanced: it will take into account the interests of citizens, as well as create clear and equal working conditions for regional operators, including new market participants.

мусор
Photo: IZVESTIA/Eduard Kornienko

The rejection of the measurement method is due to its significant disadvantages. Such studies require significant investments of time, finances and human resources, and their results are not always representative. The indicators can be influenced by seasonal fluctuations, the specifics of specific observation periods, as well as the quality of the organization of the measurements themselves. In addition, the lack of uniform standards and coordination between regions led to the fact that standards in different regions could vary significantly and be incomparable.

The comparative analysis method, on the contrary, reduces the influence of these factors. It allows you to use a more stable and verified database, makes calculations more predictable and transparent, and also gives the waste management system a more flexible tool for further development and regulatory adjustments.

The cost of error

The essence of the reform is to legalize the comparative analysis method, which allows regions to abandon mandatory long-term waste measurements, Maxim Maksimov, PhD in Economics, Associate Professor at the Department of Innovation and Industrial Policy Management at Plekhanov Russian University of Economics, told Izvestia.

The regions were rigidly tied to field measurements: specialists traveled to container sites and recorded waste volumes for seven days each season. This process took a lot of time, required significant costs and did not guarantee accuracy — the data could be distorted, and the approval of standards was delayed for years.

"As for the impact on tariffs, the new system should make them more reasonable," the expert noted. — Previously, due to measurement errors, the standards could be either overestimated or underestimated, which led to drastic changes in fees. Now, calculations are trying to bring the actual amount of waste generation closer, which is likely to avoid such spikes and make accruals more stable.

мусор
Photo: IZVESTIA/Pavel Volkov

The refusal to take measurements is explained by their complexity and unreliability in practice. Significant deviations in standards, including critical ones, have been identified in many regions. Taking measurements required high qualifications and time, which were often not enough. In addition, the changes have also affected medical institutions: Class "A" waste can now also be calculated using a new formula, eliminating the need for seasonal measurements.

The comparative analysis method is considered simpler and more convenient for many regions, since it is analytical in nature and simplifies the calculation process itself, Maxim Chirkov, associate professor of the Department of Economic Policy and Economic Measurements at the State University of Management, confirmed in an interview with Izvestia. Unlike measurements, there is no need to carry out a large number of measurements — the necessary indicators can be determined by comparing data with acceptable accuracy.

According to the expert, the transition to this method is unlikely to significantly affect residents or waste removal tariffs, since errors are possible in both approaches — both in measurements and in comparative analysis.

— The refusal to take measurements is explained by the fact that these are costly and lengthy procedures that require a large amount of work. However, they also do not exclude errors. As a result, the comparative method turns out to be more effective in many cases," he believes.

Переведено сервисом «Яндекс Переводчик»

Live broadcast